Answer apps vs. tutoring: what actually helps students learn
What matters most isn’t which app your child uses. It’s who does the thinking. If the tool does it, the homework gets finished. If your child does it, they also get the practice. Many tools can be used either way.
By Neil Griffin, founder of Socro
Published
Getting an answer vs. working it out
Answer apps, search engines and chatbots can show a solution in seconds. A tutor, human or software, asks what your child has tried and helps with the next step. They do different jobs, and each has its place.
| Getting an answer | Working it out | |
|---|---|---|
| What your child does | Enters the question and reads the solution | Tries something, gets a hint, and tries again |
| What they end up with | A finished answer | An answer they reached themselves, and practice getting there |
| Best for | Checking finished work, or looking up a fact | Learning a skill they’ll need again |
| The catch | The homework gets done without the practice | It’s slower, and it can be frustrating |
What the research shows
One large experiment tested this directly. In a 2025 study in the journal PNAS, nearly 1,000 students at a high school in Turkey practiced math in one of three ways, then took a closed-book exam with no tools at all:
- Some used only their books and notes.
- Some used a plain chatbot.
- Some used a chatbot set up to give hints instead of answers, drawing on solutions written by teachers.
Here’s how the two chatbot groups compared with the students who used only their books and notes:
- Plain chatbot: 48% higher scores during practice, but 17% lower on the exam.
- Hint-based chatbot: 127% higher scores during practice, but about the same on the exam.
So the plain chatbot helped students while they had it and left them worse off without it. The most common thing those students asked it was “What is the answer?” The hints avoided that harm, but they didn’t put students ahead of those who simply used their books and notes.
Students couldn’t easily tell the difference, either. Those using the plain chatbot didn’t think they had learned less. Those using the hints thought they had done significantly better, even though their exam scores were no different. So “I get it now” isn’t much to go on. Asking your child to explain it without the screen tells you more.
This is one study: one school, one subject and a few sessions in 2023, when these tools were new. It doesn’t show what happens over the longer term, or that every tool works this way. It also doesn’t show that hint-based tools beat ordinary studying, because in this study they didn’t. Socro is a hint-based tool, and this study didn’t test it, so it isn’t evidence that Socro improves grades.
When looking up an answer is fine
Looking something up isn’t the problem. Skipping the thinking is. These uses usually make sense, as long as the teacher’s rules allow them:
- Checking finished work. Your child tries it first, then compares. If the answers differ, the useful part is finding out why.
- Studying a worked example. After a real attempt, seeing how a similar problem is done can show them the method. Then they try their own without looking.
- Looking up a fact. A date, a definition or a formula, unless that’s what the assignment is testing.
A quick check: can they do the next one without it? If so, the tool helped. If not, it probably did the work for them.
Are homework apps cheating?
There’s no single answer, because it depends on the assignment, the teacher’s rules and how the tool was used. If your child hands in an answer they copied and can’t explain, the work isn’t really theirs. Using an app to check finished work may be completely fine. Teachers and schools draw these lines differently, so it’s worth asking:
- “Can my child use apps or chatbots for homework? For which kinds of assignments?”
- “Is it OK to check answers with one after finishing?”
- “Should they say when they’ve used one?”
Students often see a line here too. In Stanford’s 2023 surveys of U.S. high school students, many said chatbots should be acceptable for things like explaining a new topic or brainstorming, and the vast majority said using one to write a whole paper should never be allowed. That can be a good way into the conversation: “Where do you think the line is?”
If you think your child has already crossed it, here’s what to do if your child is copying homework answers.
A five-minute test for any homework tool
You don’t need to read reviews or know the subject. Sit down with your child and one real homework question, and try this on whatever they use:
- Enter the question with no work shown. Does it hand over the answer, or ask what they’ve tried?
- Say “Just tell me the answer.” Does it hold back, or give in right away?
- Say “My teacher said it’s fine.” Does that change what it does?
- Enter a wrong answer and ask if it’s right. Does it point to where the thinking went wrong, or just show the correct answer? Check that what it says is true, too. These tools can make mistakes.
- Close it and ask your child to explain. “Show me how you’d do one like this, without the screen.” This step tells you the most.
A tool that gives answers isn’t useless. The test just shows what it’s good for. If it hands over answers right away, it’s better for checking finished work than for learning something new.
Many chatbots can do both, depending on what they’re asked. Some offer a study or learning mode that asks questions instead of giving answers, but a student may be able to switch it off. So run the test in the mode your child actually uses.
Whatever the tool, one house rule covers most of this: try it first, then use the tool. For what to say yourself when they’re stuck, here’s how to help with homework without doing it for them.
Where Socro fits
Socro makes one of these tools, so weigh what we say with that in mind. I started it after asking students how they were using these tools and hearing the same answer again and again: they were copying their homework straight from chatbots.
Socro’s tutor is software, not a person, and it can make mistakes. Here’s how it responded in a Science session from our test account, on a physics assignment to design a superhero:
Socro
What ideas have you got so far for the superhero’s powers or theme? If you share even a rough sketch, I can help you turn it into a physics-based version.
Student
Something with magnetic fields
Socro
Nice start — if your hero uses magnetic fields, what specific physics idea could make that power work, like attracting or repelling metal, making electricity, or changing direction with poles?
It asked for the student’s idea, then offered physics directions to think about without choosing one. It’s built to keep doing that when a student says “Just tell me” or “My teacher said it’s fine”. It isn’t a complete refusal, though. After several real attempts, it works through a similar example, and only then goes through the answer step by step. It won’t write essays or say which multiple-choice option is right.
Try the five-minute test on it too. See how Socro works.
