How to help with homework without doing it for them
Ask questions instead of giving answers, and leave the pencil in your child’s hand. You don’t need to know the material to do this. Your job is to help them work out what they already know and what to try next.
By Neil Griffin, founder of Socro
Published
Why asking works better than telling
When you explain a problem, you do the thinking. Your child gets a finished answer, but they aren’t necessarily any better at finding the next one. When you ask a question, the thinking stays with them.
Research on parents and homework points the same way, with some caveats. A 2023 review of 20 studies on math homework found that students tended to do a little better in math when their parents gave them room to solve problems themselves. They tended to do a little worse when parents pressured them or stepped in without being asked.
These are small links, and they don’t prove that one causes the other. A student who is already struggling may simply get more pressure at home. So this isn’t a promise of better grades. It’s a reason to start with a question.
Picture a student stuck on a word problem who says, “I don’t get it.” You could explain the whole thing. Or you could ask, “What is it asking you to find?” Reading it out loud, they might notice they’ve been working toward the wrong number. If so, they’ve fixed it themselves, and you didn’t need to know the method.
What to say when they’re stuck
These phrases fit most subjects. Change the words so they sound like you.
When they say “I don’t get it”
That’s too broad to help with yet, so narrow it down:
- “Read me the question. What is it asking you to do?”
- “Which part makes sense so far?”
- “Show me where you stopped.”
When they say “Just tell me the answer”
They may be tired or frustrated, so acknowledge that before you offer a smaller step:
- “This one’s annoying, I can see that. What have you tried so far?”
- “Is there an example in your notes or textbook that looks like this?”
- “I’m not going to give you the answer, but I’ll stay here while you try the first step.”
When the answer is wrong
Try not to point at the mistake right away. If they explain their steps, they may catch it themselves:
- “Talk me through how you got this.”
- “Does that answer seem reasonable? Why or why not?”
- “How could you check it?”
If they still don’t see it, point to the line rather than the fix: “Tell me what you did here.”
When the page is blank
Any start gives you both something to work with, even a wrong one:
- “What’s the first thing you’d need to figure out?”
- “What do you remember from class about this?”
- “Have you done a problem like this before? What did you do first?”
When they can’t start writing
Talking is often easier than writing:
- “If you were just telling me, what would you say?”
- “What’s the one thing you want your reader to understand?”
Then try: “Write down what you just said. You can fix it later.” Try not to reword their sentences, even when you could make them better. Ask “What are you trying to say here?” and let them find the words.
When questions aren’t enough
Sometimes your child doesn’t know the method, and no question will fix that. It’s fine to show them. Use a similar problem rather than the assigned one, work through it out loud, then hand the pencil back so they can try their own.
When you don’t know the material either
Many parents run into this, and it’s fine to say so: “I don’t remember how to do this. Let’s figure out where we can find out.” That shows your child what to do when they’re stuck, which is useful in itself. Then try these in order:
- Have them teach you. “Pretend I missed class. What did your teacher show you?” Explaining it can show them exactly where they got lost.
- Go to the class materials. Look at their notes, the textbook and any examples from the teacher. Methods may differ from how you learned them, and the teacher may expect a particular one, so start with what the class is using.
- Look it up together. Search for the topic name from the worksheet, plus “explained” or “example”. You’re looking for an explanation of the idea, not the answer to this exact question.
- Write down a question for the teacher. “I can do the first two steps, but I don’t know why we divide here” gives a teacher much more to work with than “I don’t get it”.
When to step back
It’s easy to slide from helping into doing, especially when it’s late and you just want it finished. A few signs you may be doing too much:
- You’re talking more than they are.
- You’re holding the pencil or typing.
- They check your face before every step.
- The work is starting to sound like you.
When you notice one of these, try: “Do the next two on your own. I’ll come back in ten minutes.”
You also don’t have to catch every mistake. A wrong answer shows the teacher what your child still needs help with, and a perfect page can hide it.
If you’re both getting frustrated, take a break: “Let’s both take ten minutes.” Nobody does their best thinking in the middle of an argument.
When it’s time to stop for the night
If your child has made a real attempt and more time isn’t helping, stopping can be the right call. A short note tells the teacher where to help, and it’s even better if your child writes it:
“I worked on this for about 30 minutes and got stuck on question 4. I understood the first part, but not how to set up the equation.”
It’s worth asking the teacher early on how they’d like to hear about this.
If this keeps happening, or your child seems overwhelmed or very anxious about school, talk to their teacher or school counselor.
Where Socro fits
You can’t always sit down with them, and your child may turn to an app or chatbot when you’re not there. Here’s how to tell whether a homework tool is helping them learn.
Socro is a homework tutor built on the same idea as this guide, with questions and hints instead of answers. Socro’s tutor is software, not a person, and it can make mistakes. See how Socro works.
